“ The sign inside says “Get Lost In The Sauce” and I most certainly did. Square style pizza is not typically my go-to but WOW this was good. I asked the staff what the best slice is and he told me Pepperoni and get the corner piece. This thing was loaded with roni’s and it was amazing. I ordered a side ranch too a cold tall boy beer from a local brewery. Great spot and I can’t wait to go back ”

“ Really lovely pizza spot that I would definitely come back to. I really enjoyed the slices, and I’m surprised there aren’t more people lining up. Perhaps it’s because they are very close to L’Industrie, but I think this place is not too far off in terms of quality. I enjoyed the classic slice and the pepperoni Sicilian pie equally. My partner got the buffalo chicken, which I liked more than I thought I would. They have some really interesting flavours, though, and I would love to come back and try more. Solid pizza with very little wait—I dig it! ”

“ Village Square Pizza in the West Village is an absolute gem! The slices here are truly unique, standing out from the usual New York pizza spots with their incredible flavor and top-notch ingredients. Every bite is bursting with quality, and you can tell a lot of care goes into each slice. It's underrated compared to the more well-known spots, but that's what makes it even better. If you're looking for a delicious and distinctive pizza experience, this is the place to go. 5/5. Also, open late! ”

“ better than the overhyped l’industrie - no 2 hour long line, staff was nice, the chicken bacon ranch was ”

“ Do yourself a favor and get the pepperoni pizza. Staff is always super friendly! Love this place :) ”

“ This was the best rectangular shaped (Sicilian style?) pizza by the slice I’ve ever had. It was fluffy on the inside, just the right amount of crisp along the outside edges, and boy was that pepperoni nice and crispy as well. Wow. I’m salivating just thinking about it..this place is worth walking the extra 6-8 minutes to come here instead of some random pizza by the slice that may not be as good. Just remember this is the rectangular style pizza, not your thin crust triangular shaped slice of New York pizza. I think this is way better. FYI: 10 minimum credit card charge, otherwise Cash or Venmo (no minimum). ”

“ I’m a big fan of Village Square Pizza. When my wife lived in the lower east side, I used to eat at that location every time I wanted pizza. Their pepperoni cup pizza is incredible and some of my favorite anywhere, especially with hot honey. But I found out yesterday how good their white slice is. Had it fresh out of the oven and MAN it’s good. If I’m ever in the mood for a second slice, this will now fight for that spot with vodka sauce. In short, eat pizza here, it’s so damn good, I love it! ”

“ Awesome, the square pepperoni slice had perfect flavour and texture. Unpretentious spot. Great for if you don’t want to queue for L’industrie but still want a great NY slice ”